Fire 0, Real Salt Lake 0: A Supporter’s View

Chicago_fire_logoReal_salt_lake_logo

It wasn’t pretty, but you can call the scoreless tie between the Chicago Fire and Real Salt Lake a fair result. It figured that no goals would be scored when the league’s two toughest defense squared off, but seeing so many missed chances was still a bit puzzling.

With every league game ending in a tie, the Fire-RSL result kept RSL in first place in the West and kept Chicago in playoff position. Whether either of these things remains the same a week from now remains to be seen.

SBI correspondent Stephen Wattles and Scott McAllister watched (most of) the match and shared their views on the match with us:

Large crowd at Toyota Park treated to ugly game

By STEPHEN WATTLES

It wouldn’t be a summer of MLS without nights like this. Sticky evenings when the play drags a bit, the play is sloppy and when you sit down to write about it there isn’t a heck of a lot to say, since not that much happened.

The 0-0 tie between the Fire and Real Salt Lake wasn’t the worst of these ‘midsummer classics’ played at Toyota Park. Both teams did create a few chances and rattled the woodwork on several occasions, but the quality of the strikers on the field for both teams never gave you a sense that the game would have a goal.

It’s really too bad since the largest home crowd of the season was on hand for the evening and it would have been nice to bring a few back with the promise of more goals. Unfortunately, more goals is not the calling card of this particular team.

In three games in April and May versus New England and New York, the Fire tallied 12 goals. In the other thirteen games played this season the Fire has scored, you guessed it, 12 goals. So for more then three quarters of their schedule, the Fire have now averaged less than a goal a game.

The offense is the reason the Fire are closer to out of the playoffs than they are to the top of the standings. The offense will also be the reason that the Fire will not make the playoffs unless something is done about it.

It’s impossible to blame the defense; still the league best by a significant margin and Saturday night was a clear example why.  The combination of Jon Busch coming up with the big save, the four in the back being solid if somewhat erratic, and Logan Pause pitching in once again impeccably, reading the game and continuing to display his knack to show up in the right place at the right time.

That combination has combined for six clean sheets thus far this season; unfortunately the anemic offense has had the trick turned on them six times as well. The reasons for its struggles were all too clear on this night as well. Besides the aforementioned players that form the defensive core and CuauhtĂ©moc Blanco those taking the field are young and still primarily untested. 

On this night, the undersized Chris Rolfe was reasonably anonymous, marked out by the physical and effective RSL defenders. Justin Mapp was his usual self, electric at times yet invisible for long stretches. Stephen King tried and failed to fill the hole left by the season’s talisman John Thorrington’s suspension. Which inevitably leads us to Chad Barrett, whose struggles continued.

It has been speculated that it is confidence that is holding Chad back and I concur. It is clear in his reaction to misses, calls against him, and even his interactions with teammates. But it is not only his confidence that is holding him back. It appears that by and large, his teammates have lost confidence in him. So that on the occasion that Barrett does get himself it the proper position his teammates aren’t looking for him.

Dennis Hamlett saw this, but unfortunately circumstance has conspired from him correcting it, with first Andy Herron and then Calen Carr going down the second that they took Barrett’s spot. If Herron is unable to return. it must fall to Thomas Frankowski or the unproven rookie Patrick Nyarko to take a shot, as something needs to be done to turn this offense around.

The hope is that the ultimate answer to this issue will arrive after a few warm-up games in Beijing but it won’t hurt to work on Plan D in the meantime. Since the D can only carry this team so far.

———–

Not sharp, but road point will due for RSL

By SCOTT McALLISTER

For better or worse, there are few things in my life that are a higher priority than soccer. Family is one of those things that will trump it every time, and is the reason I missed most of the first half. I tuned in just in time to see Dema Kovalenko drop a nice through ball back for Chris Rolfe to sidestep Nick Rimando and fire into the side netting. Even though the score was tied at 0-0 my first image of the game didn’t give me warm fuzzies.

My next memory was another defensive miscue, this time from Nat Borchers just before the break. The part that you’ll see in highlight reels is Chad Barrett driving his shot off the post while Jamison Olave was pushing him toward the sideline. The play was made possible by a wild sliding tackle attempt from Borchers on Rolfe. Borchers completely missed everything by going to ground and provided Rolfe with the time and space to pick out Barrett.

Bringing Robbie Findley and Kenny Deuchar on in the second half is still a good move, I guess. I understand it worked in the last game, so why change something that isn’t broken. I just wish those guys could do the same stuff for the full 90.  Tino Nunez and Yura Movsysian are not bad strikers, but they’re not the best on the team.

The way the second half progressed only added to the stress of the start of my watching experience.  My source of a relief was the incredible play of Rimando.  The back line in front of him consistently absorbed the immense pressure from the Fire, which still broke through from time to time. Rimando was on his game and I would agree with the television commentators that he would be deserving of the game ball.

As a whole RSL didn’t have the sharpest of games. There were giveaways in the midfield that were uncharacteristic, and opportunities for Rimando to come up big. You never want those moments, but appreciate a ‘keeper who can step up on those occasions’ when they arise. At least Salt Lake remain at the top of the table for another week.  And, as the old soccer cliche goes, as long as you tie on the road and win at home you’ll be in good shape. Right now, the season is still pointing towards success for RSL.

This entry was posted in MLS- Chicago Fire, MLS- Real Salt Lake. Bookmark the permalink.

15 Responses to Fire 0, Real Salt Lake 0: A Supporter’s View

  1. brett says:

    stephen- “The offense is the reason the Fire are closer to out of the playoffs than they are to the top of the standings”

    while i agree that if we had a more stellar front line we’d be sitting pretty, but in all honesty, we have a couple games in hand and currently rest at 3rd place in the league… however, thats not saying much, as 5 points seperate 3rd place from 12th place…. its a close point of the season, and the 2 pts dropped last night can always be costly… as we found out last season when we earned MANY draws late in the season (losing the leads) and forced us to battle til the last game…

    i see some of our additions coming in to aid in pushing Rolfe back up top..

  2. Fumar says:

    I’m not really with either of you on the ugly factor. Although goals would have been nice, this game was exciting end to end. Both goalkeepers were given a workout and so was the woodwork. So although noone broke through for a goal, there were several efforts both ways that were desreving of one.

  3. guillemo says:

    I will have to disagree with the assumption that confidence is what is holding Chad Barrett back. I believe that being bad is holding Chad Barrett back.

  4. Fumar says:

    I can’t agree with any of you that this was an ugly game. Although there were no goals there were several efforts that were deserving of one, with both goalkeepers and the woodwork getting a workout. It was a fun game to watch despite the disappointing result.

  5. Fumar says:

    sorry double posted. I didn’t see the first one go up.

  6. Randomher0723 says:

    I hear Freddy Adu to Monaco is a done deal, any news?

  7. Drew says:

    i agree fumar, thought it was a pretty exciting game overall.

  8. MattC says:

    I also must have watched a different game then Steve and Scott, because to me it was very entertaining. There honestly should have been a couple of goals on each side if not for some terrific goal keeping and defending. Busch’s saves on Findley and Movsisyan were truly amazing.

    The second half did drag a little as you could tell the heat took it out of both teams (RSL more). The one downside of playing the summer schedule is that the heat really negatively effects the quality of play.

    Last point, as an RSL fan, I was actually most impressed with Rolfe of all the attackers. Stephen mentioned that he was anonymous but I disagree. I thought that he created the most dangerous chances for the Fire, especially in the first half.

  9. RSLhomem says:

    I agree with Randomher and Fumar. I thought the game was very exciting. I was on the edge of my couch almost the whole match, and both teams put together some great sequences. But defense (including the ‘keepers) and the woodwork were kings in this game.

  10. Scott says:

    @MattC and @RSLhomem, Thanks for your comments. As I mentioned in the article, I would whole heartedly agree with you on the goalkeeping. Both Rimando and Busch were playing out of their minds. I also came off my chair when Findley broke through only to have Busch get enough on it to make the shot hit the frame.

    Thanks again for the feedback.

  11. thomas says:

    How can you call a game ugly where 20,000 spectators are in almost constant pains from oohing and aahing?

    Barrett is suffering by comparison with the elephant which hasn’t quite yet entered the room (in the shape of a certain Brian McBride), which would be off-putting for any young player. MoJo is playing nasty here as the prolongation of the negotiating process is making the Fire organisation take their eye off the ball.

    That said some midseason games are bound to fail to live up to expectation because the play-off structure demeans the balance of the season and reduces the competitivity of nights like these – if I could choose between the two I’d abandon the post-season from next season, now that there is the Concacaf CL to look at.

  12. KingSnake says:

    “I will have to disagree with the assumption that confidence is what is holding Chad Barrett back. I believe that being bad is holding Chad Barrett back.”

    Good one!

  13. Stephen Wattles says:

    The ugly in the title was a bit strong, I agree, but the game was played 18 to 18 with little development of real solid scoring chances by either team. A few half chances ended up testing the goalies but even the posts Williams and Barrett hit were on fairly specualtive efforts and the Fire’s best chance (Rolfe’s) was on an error by RSL. But I won’t argue significantly with the comments posted. The first couple paragraphs of my piece are not to far off from what you all are saying.

    Brett – In terms of the Fire’s position and games in hand I’m not trying to declare the sky is faling but considering we had as many as three or four games in hand on some teams and have lost ground to most teams as we’ve caught up is dosappointing. The one game we have remaining on NE and Columbus won’t get us better than a tie for second five off the top still, whihc is why I’ve stopped hanging my hat on those. Especially since DC can catch us as soon as tonight with the game they have in hand.

    Here’s to the Fire finding another late season gear whether it be McBride fueled or not!

  14. firecop says:

    Let’s be honest ! Barrett just keeps choking. If the Fire want to win, why doesn’t Hamlett try something new. Same lineup, same result. Why does he insist on one inept forward. Most teams use two strikers up front, but Hamlett being the mastermind that he is refuses to change anything. If Barrett continues to start and play the majority of game minutes, FIRE LOSES !! over and over again. Dump Barrett. If you won’t dump him–bench him

  15. brett says:

    stephen- but the 1 game in hand can also strengthen our lead in the standings…. 5 points from NE could also result in a 5 pt adv over quite a number of teams….

    i agree we had games that shouldve gone better for our sake, but failed to maintain the leads… but to claim that we are closer to “out of the playoffs” then “top of the league” is folly… as i stated, we still currently rest at 3rd place… and i also pointed out (which you elaborated on) that we are merely a game away from dropping loads of places (you mentioned we’ve allowed teams to catch up)…

    but i agree with you in the long run, lets hope for another splurge like last season…